It’s no surprise that when shopping for makeup, you will find yourself running into a massive amount of pencil eyeliners. The pencil eyeliner is like the primary fine art tool of cosmetics. So no question, having the best pencil eyeliner is a must.
Em Cosmetics Matte Gel Pencil
4.1 out of 5 stars
Pat McGrath Labs Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil
4.4 out of 5 stars
Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner
4.0 out of 5 stars
Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Eyeliner
4.3 out of 5 stars
Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Pencil
4.5 out of 5 stars
When it comes to the world of makeup, eyeliner is one of the more essential parts of your arsenal. For most, the very first beauty product they ever bought was some form of eyeliner.
So what exactly makes a pencil eyeliner so important?
Your eyeliner creates a pretty significant impact on the overall appearance of your face. The right eyeliner will intensify the shape of your eyes, giving them a serious, dramatic, or more cat-like touch.
Unlike the liquid form, pencils are ideal for blurring or creating a smoky effect around the eye area. They are also most preferred over liquid liners for safe use on the waterline of your eye.
Line and Define Your Eyes with the Best Pencil Eyeliner
The pencil is eyeliner in its most traditional form, coming in a spectrum of many different fun colors. As the name suggests, it has a pencil-like shape and is sometimes applied by twisting or pushing the point out. Some pencils can even be sharpened with an eyeliner sharpener, while most gel pencils are retractable.
When it comes to eyeliner, the results are nearly limitless.
Whether you’re looking for sharp, bold lines or just accents of additional color, you can explicitly give off the illusion of smaller, larger, or brighter eyes. The options are endless.
The Best Pencil Liners That You Can Get
With so many eyeliner options out on the market today, it can be increasingly difficult to choose among them. You do not want to end up with an eyeliner that smudges, bleeds, or clumps in the corners of your eyes. You want a reliable eyeliner that stays in place and can outlast the day and night.
We have gone through several high rated eyeliners to narrow them down. And now we present you with the top five best pencil eyeliner options so you can shape, shade, and give your eyes wings!
4.1 out of 5 stars
- Glides on effortlessly like a liquid
- Ultra-rich color and intense payoff
- Waterproof and long-lasting
- Gentle enough for the waterline
- Cruelty-free & Vegan
Em Cosmetics knows a thing or two about the importance of good pencil eyeliner. It’s no surprise, coming from a creator with an extensive background in fine art, where quality pencils are a must.
The Em Cosmetics Matte Gel Pencil is enriched to give you a super smooth matte finish. It has a creamy consistency that seems to melt onto your skin as you slide it across your eye line. As it promises, It glides on smoothly and ensures you a full day of looking great. There is practically zero effort involved, as the creamy texture of this pencil eyeliner also makes it incredibly easy for you to blend.
This fantastic gel pencil comes in a deep, intense ultra-black, which, although matte, doesn’t become lighter as it sets. It is made up of a perfect blend of the darkest color intensity precision liners and is long-lasting.
And it’s not too expensive either! You can get this best pencil eyeliner at an average price range between $15 and $20.
The only downside is that it only comes in black, and it isn’t retractable. When the point becomes blunt, you must use an eyeliner sharpener to sharpen it.
The other minor issue is that you will need to use an oil-based makeup remover to make it easier to remove. This downside also has a silver lining — that means that the eyeliner will stay in place all day.
According to users, the Em Cosmetics Matte Gel Pencil is the holy grail of black pencil eyeliners. Reviewers reward it with a high rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Check out this great review below:
4.1 out of 5 stars
Many know McGrath for her unique, adventurous, and innovative makeup techniques, which reflect in the quality of her products. Often being called the “mother” of the makeup world, Pat McGrath Labs Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil does not disappoint.
This is the definition of a traditional pencil eyeliner, but with the additional benefit of perma-gel technology. This technology allows for a smooth and vivid dark stroke with each application. The pencil is also waterproof and gives off an opaque finish without worry of any stretching or pulling of the skin. It is Incredibly long-lasting, and will not smudge as you go about your day.
This pencil comes in a few intensely dark colors, including xtreme black, blitz blue, black coffee, and blitz brown. It also has an additional color option in taupe, called “shade.” Taupe is close to the color of your skin tone. This pigment is often used to cover up any mistakes you might make while using other liner colors.
It is a little bit more expensive than the other eyeliners, but well worth it. You can find it in the price range of $20 to $25 per pencil.
The only issue customers seem to have is that the liner is a bit less reliable on the waterline of your eye. If you plan to wear your liner for over 10 hours, you might notice a little crumbling or smudging on the lower lash. However, it is a minor problem and can be touched up easily.
Customers agree that the ultra glide eye pencil is impressive, giving it an outstanding rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars on Influenster.
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sephora is a lead retailer of many brand-name cosmetics. They even have their own brand, known as the Sephora Collection. All products included in the company-owned brand are known for being high quality and reliable.
As the name suggests, the Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner comes in retractable packaging. It is two-sided, meaning that one end of the eyeliner has a pencil tip, while the other end has a sharpener and smudger.
The liner is also waterproof, making it very safe to use on your eyes. The formula is smooth and creamy, with great pigmentation that shows little to no fading.
This top quality pencil is available in traditional black and brown, as well as more than 10 other, more adventurous colors. These colors feature both matte and shimmering textures for endlessly exciting results.
Sephora is well-known for its low-cost, yet top-quality, products. This liner is no exception, and is usually in a price range of anywhere from $10 to $12 per pencil.
We had a difficult time finding any drawback or flaw associated with this amazing pencil eyeliner. However, If you are looking for an ultra-fine, thin line, this liner might not be the best choice. Keep in mind that we only heard of this con once and did not personally experience it.
Many users call the Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner their go-to liner, with an impressive rating of 4.0 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Have a look at this happy customer’s video:
4.0 out of 5 stars
- The sharpener inside the cap ensures a perfect tip every time
- This waterproof product does not flake and can be used on the inner rim.
Smashbox is another well-known favorite brand in the world of cosmetics. The name reflects the goal of the company. The term Smashbox refers to a 1990s box-style camera, which created an affordable way to capture beauty in snapshots — just as the cosmetics of today allow customers to be their most beautiful without spending a fortune.
The Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Eyeliner does everything that it promises to do. It has a smooth, creamy texture that glides on perfectly. It’s also very colorful. Being waterproof, it can last for up to 12 hours or more without any noticeable smearing, fading, or bleeding. The lid keeps the point sharp, so you do not need to sharpen it.
This popular eyeliner is available in a handful of beautiful shades, including black, greens, blues, a shimmery golden brown, and more.
The eyeliner is a great purchase, with an excellent value for money at an average price range of around $20 to $22 per pencil.
Unfortunately, the new automatic sharpening design of the product does not always work as intended. In some cases, when the pencil mechanism thinks that the tip is too sharp, it chops it off. Regardless, this problem affects only those products with a flawed device and does not affect every pencil.
Most customers say that this is a contender for the best pencil eyeliner, crowning it with a rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars at Macy’s.
Just watch how it convinced this customer below:
4.5 out of 5 stars
- Marc Jacobs Mini Highliner Gel Eye Crayon (Mini Size) .013 oz.
- Blacquer (Black)
- A gel crayon eyeliner witha waterproof long wearing intense color payoff.
- NEW PRODUCT
Marc Jacobs offers a variety of luxury beauty products including premium eyeliner. The company specializes in collections of bold, unexpected products with adventurous and vivid colors
The Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Pencil is a highly creamy formula, with a blendable texture that glides on smoothly to give you an intense look that lasts for hours. It is transfer resistant, and the intensity of the colors never fades. The pencil delivers both subtle and dramatic looks according to your choice of pigment.
The available colors that this pencil comes in are just too many to list! It includes just about any color you can think of, with fun names like jazzberry and marigold. This makes it the perfect choice when you are looking to experiment with new shades.
With the look and feel of any top professional product, it is quite affordable, with an average price range of $17 to $20 per pencil.
Hardly anyone has anything wrong to say about this eyeliner. The only known flaw is that you can accidentally smash the tip. Due to the soft texture of the pencil, if you push too hard, it will flatten out. However, you can easily avoid this by taking a more gentle approach during application.
Customers agree that this is one of the best pencil eyeliners, with an amazing rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars at Sephora.
See a wonderful showcase of each vivid color below:
Best Pencil Eyeliner: The Bottom Line
When it comes to the best pencil eyeliner, it all depends on your requirement and personal preference. No matter your style, whether you prefer soft and subtle or full-on dark and dramatic, eyeliner will become your best friend.
Well, what are you waiting for? You’ve got everything you need to find the best pencil eyeliner for you.
Go pick up one of these fantastic eyeliners and create the look you’ve always wanted!