The right eyeliner enables you to completely transform your look. I should know because winged eyeliner has been my favorite style for years now. But it isn’t easy. To get the perfect wing, you need to find the best felt tip eyeliner on the market. At least, the one that works best for you.
I’m not going to lie, brush tip eyeliner is my favorite thing right now. Back in the day I only ever used felt tip liner because it’s much easier to apply. But then I bought an NYX brush tip by accident. It ended up being a do or die moment because I had places to go and had to make it work.
But let me tell you, it was the biggest learning curve of all time. A brush tip is so flexible and takes a very steady hand. Up until that point I had always been spoiled by the firm but forgiving felt tip.
So if you hate liquid eyeliner, there’s a good chance you have been using the wrong brush. Using a felt tip will feel like using a pen. It’s much easier to control the product and get a clean line.
In the end, a felt tip is always going to be my favorite. Plus, it’s the best choice if you’re a new user of liquid eyeliner because you will have so much more control. It’s also much easier to get ready in a hurry.
So if you are always in a rush, it’s time to get the best felt tip eyeliner to save time, effort, and actually achieve the look you were going for.
What to Look for in an Eyeliner Pen
When it comes to eyeliner, you might think you need to get a high-end brand and call it a day. Although before you get to shopping, there are a few things you should know. After all, there are so many options out there, and you need to do a little exploring, starting with the best felt tip liner.
For one thing, there are actually five different types of eyeliner, which includes:
Each option is different in application, and the final product will vary. It is handy to have a variety because they are great for achieving different looks.
The pencil and retractable varieties are similar. However, a pencil will give you a soft and subtle makeup look. It’s ideal for a “no makeup” look with a touch of definition.
The gel liners and retractable liners are also perfect if you want to create a smokey eye because they are much easier to smudge to perfection. They aren’t the most precise, but that is also the point in most cases.
However, it’s a good idea to get a waterproof version because they are built to move. If you have oily skin, you might end up looking a bit like a raccoon throughout the day.
In my daily routine, I use a retractable cream liner for my waterline before I use a brush or felt tip liner. It goes on much thicker and is perfect for a bold look. Then I use a brush or felt tip liner above my lash line to create a wing or a very crisp line.
Keep in mind that they are supposed to dry in place, so they aren’t great for much more than a crisp line.
Felt tip vs. brush tip
One thing is for sure; all eyeliners are unique in application, color, and final product. It can depend on the style and the brand. Still, that being the case, felt tip and brush tip eyeliners are the easiest to mix up.
Some of them are remarkably similar because they look like pens. They both brag about a precise tip. Everything seems the same until you get them home and try to apply.
As I mentioned before, I started using brush liners when I bought one by accident. It was also so hard to get used to, but I ended up falling in love. Although, before you click out of here to find a brush liner, I have a few warnings for you.
A brush liner is not for beginners if it is a dip liner. It is messier and harder to control. It’s similar to nail polish in some ways.
When you have too much product on the brush, it’s going to get out of control quickly. In the same way, when you don’t have enough product on the brush, you aren’t going to get the crisp line you were looking for.
Felt is just easier
On the other hand, a felt tip liner is the best for beginners because it is easier to control with the stiffer tip and the steady flow of liquid. So it is much harder to make a mess, and there is less of a chance that you will get it in your eye.
Trust me, getting liquid eyeliner in your eye is no walk in the park. It burns and makes you look a bit like a demon in a horror movie. When you’re crying black tears, you will definitely be wishing for that safer felt tip.
That is why the felt tip eyeliner is at the top of the list when it comes to precision and saving time. You won’t have to worry about the same mishaps that you would with a brush tip liquid eyeliner.
How We Reviewed
We came up with this list of the best felt tip eyeliner choices through customer reviews. All our ratings come from the average customer ratings from Amazon and Ulta Beauty.
The location of the rating depends on the availability of the product, not a store preference. So feel free to look for these products in local stores.
The products are also not in any particular order. They are merely the top choices based on the quality and performance of the product.
Price range to expect
We are trying to give you a wide variety of products which will also come with a wide variety of prices. You can expect to pay anywhere from $4 to $30 for these eyeliners.
The various prices of these items are according to brand and quality. High-end brands can ask more for their products because they often use high-quality ingredients and have a well-established name.
No matter the price, keep in mind that they are all applied similarly. You may be pleasantly surprised by some more affordable items.
The Best Felt Tip Eyeliner Options on the Market
If you are on the hunt for the best felt tip eyeliner, you came to the right place.
These items are the ones that have the top reviews by customers. It’s time to end the search and try something new. You might be able to pull off that cat-eye after all.
If you are looking for an eyeliner that goes on as smooth as butter, Stila Stay All Day is a fantastic choice. The ultra-fine felt tip gives you the ultimate control for thin lines and bold looks.
You can even take your look over the top because it comes in nine unique colors. Although, it does come in black for a traditional style.
Stila All Day eyeliner is waterproof, and customers love it because it does not smudge or flake and lasts all day. What more could you ask for?
- CONTROL FREAK - Perversion Fine-Point Eye Pen’s innovative brush tip lays down semi-matte, blacker-than-black pigment...
- LONG-LASTING - Our paraben-free, cruelty-free waterproof eyeliner keeps on going until you say “when"—from office...
- PRECISE APPLICATION - The ultra-fine, flexible brush tip gives you full control over your shape and flick.
Urban Decay is an extremely popular brand right now, and their Urban Decay Perversion waterproof fine-point eye pen is true to the brand. It has an ultra-fine felt tip and a constant flow, dries quickly, and is easy to guide.
As a bonus, it goes on in an intense black for a quick application. So it can be applied in a super thin line for an everyday look or bold line for a night out.
However, you should keep in mind that many people mentioned that it does have a shiny finish. So if you are looking for a matte eyeliner, this might not be the best felt tip eyeliner for you.
Overall, this waterproof eyeliner is long-lasting, doesn’t run or smudge, and has a constant flow. Plus, it is 100 percent cruelty-free for those of you who are careful in your makeup selection.
- High-tech Japanese formula is long-wearing, water-resistant and smudge-resistant
- Ultra-precise brush-tip applicator: Innovative and easy to use eye lining tool delivers effortless,
- Hypoallergenic, fragrance free, paraben free, dermatologist approved, safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
The Physicians Formula Eye Booster has a unique formula with extra benefits. Not only will you be able to get a fabulous makeup look, but it also contains a lash boosting serum.
If you are skeptical of makeup products that brag about giving you longer lashes, you should check out the reviews. Many people praised this formula for giving them longer or fuller lashes in a matter of months and consider this the best felt tip eyeliner because of it.
Besides that little bonus, this felt tip eyeliner has a great pen-line tip and goes on smooth. It is not a very bold black, but it is long-lasting and does not smudge. The softer black is perfect for a crisp line, but might not make for an awesome winged look.
- LIQUID EYELINER PEN: Define your eyes with NYX Professional Makeup That's The Point Eyeliner. This collection of rich...
- ALL ABOUT THE TIPS: These black liquid eyeliner pens features seven incredible felt tips! From paddle-shaped to small...
- ALL EYES ON EYE MAKEUP: Complete your look with our full range of NYX Professional Makeup eye makeup products from...
NYX Professional Makeup is a highly affordable brand and its line of That’s the Point eyeliner is well loved.
You can find this product in an incredible selection of seven different tips. They all come in black and have an opaque matte finish. The felt tip you choose depends entirely on your personal preference, and all seven felt tips offer complete control.
- VOLUMINOUS SMOLDERING EYELINER: The secret to its intensity is in the dark kajal formula, a richly intense black...
- L'OREAL EYELINER: Use our best eyeliners to achieve an everyday eye look or a bold cat eye look; Choose from a variety...
- CREATE YOUR PERFECT EYE MAKEUP LOOK with our collection of mascaras, achieve sleek lines with smudge proof eyeliner, add...
If you are on the search for an extremely opaque black eyeliner, the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner in noir is an incredible choice. It has an ultra-fine long tip that gives you total control while you get ready for your day. It’s perfect for any look, and you can apply it as thin or bold as you like.
You also don’t have to worry about this liner going anywhere. It might not be waterproof, but it’s not budging.
You might have to loosen the purse strings a bit with this one, but it’s well worth the price. The Lancome Artliner Precision eyeliner is arguably one of the best felt tip eyeliner choices on the market. It is highly pigmented, precise, and all-around effortless to use.
So you might have to fork over a lot (for eyeliner) at one time, but you won’t have to keep going back as often.
One of the things that they couldn’t praise enough was the fact that it offered long-lasting wear. Plus, the pen itself lasts a very long time, which is not standard for felt tipped liners.
- LONG-LASTING LIQUID EYELINER: The party-proof Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner with an easy-to-use felt tip allows you...
- AVAILABLE IN 2 SHADES: Choose from Blackest Black or Black Vinyl to create either an intense matte or ultra shiny finish...
- VEGAN, CRUELTY-FREE BEAUTY: Waterproof, transfer-proof and non-feathering, the vegan formula glides on smoothly in a...
Milani might sound expensive, but this is by far one of the most affordable eyeliners you can get. Most of the customers compare the Milani Eye Tech liner with well-known brands, like Kat Von D or Urban Decay. That’s pretty understandable because it goes on in an entirely black, matte line and does not smudge.
I have some personal experience with this brand, and I can say, it is not waterproof, but it definitely feels like it should be. It also goes on in a smooth application and will not smudge once it dries.
I will say, however, that it can be hard to touch up. For instance, if you’re touching up a wing, you typically have to wipe away the existing product. Otherwise, the firm felt tip causes it to crumble, and that just creates a mess. Luckily I don’t find the need to reapply very often with this bad boy.
If you are interested in trying new or lesser known brands, Eyeko skinny liquid liner is a great new option. It goes on smooth, and the skinny tip will help you achieve those thin lines for an everyday look. Although you can absolutely build it up to thick lines and cat wings without an issue.
As an added bonus, this eyeliner formula can, allegedly, boost the growth of your lashes. It is smudge proof, perfect for detail, and a crowd pleaser. Not to mention, Eyeko Skinny liquid liner is an affordable option, making it a top contender for the best felt tip eyeliner title.
Get Your Hottest Look with the Best Felt Tip Eyeliner
It’s not always easy to find the perfect eyeliner. Even when you do find it, learning how to apply liquid liner is going to be really difficult at first. But the whole process is going to be much easier if you have the right tools for the job.
This list of the best felt tip eyeliner is useful as a suggestion guide, especially for beginners. I know exactly what if feels like to stand in the makeup aisle and be totally clueless. We all imagine that perfect look in our heads, but when you buy the wrong products, it’s impossible to pull them off in real life.
We’re here to clear up the confusion for you. There no need for you to buy anything but the best felt tip eyeliner because we hunted them down for you.
Now, your art skills and freehand techniques might need some work, but at least you will have the perfect tool to practice with. Also, keep in mind that practice makes perfect.
It took me years to be happy with my ability to control my eyeliner. But using a felt tip, in the beginning, was what even made a cat-eye look possible. I’m forever grateful, and you should get cracking. It’s time to have some fun with your makeup and never stop trying new things.
We hope that this selection of the best felt tip eyeliner is a big help. We would love to hear what you think, or some of your favorites, in the comment section below!