In the eyes of many, the best eyeliner for oily lids is an impossible find. Finding a safe, natural, organic eyeliner is difficult, and the hunt becomes even more frustrating for those with oily skin. All you want to do is create intense depth and definition for your eyes. And that shouldn’t be too much to ask.
For those of us with oily eyes, trying to pull off a serious liner can be a little irritating. When your lids are oily, it can easily make your makeup slip, slide, and smudge. In an attempt to offer eyeliner with stronger resistance, many cosmetic brands use artificial additives to their products.
That doesn’t mean you have to resort to using a brand with potentially harmful ingredients to get the right look.
Why Organic Eyeliner Makes Sense
Image via Pixabay
Many conventional eyeliners contain parabens, the most widely used preservative in personal care and beauty products. These preservatives help prevent fungus, bacteria, and other microbes from growing in your favorite makeup products.
However, parabens are potentially harmful and may cause irritation and redness to those with oily or sensitive skin. Some parabens are even said to be linked to other more severe health issues, though it hasn’t been proven.
With all the contradiction of whether or not these parabens are harmful, it’s better to be safe than sorry. That’s especially true when using eyeliner since it’s applied around and on the waterline of your eye.
There are several premium quality cosmetic companies that take care ensuring that their products are free of any harmful ingredients. That way you can still achieve the perfect liner look without the risk.
All Natural Best Eyeliner for Oily Lids That Won’t Budge
It can take several frustrating minutes to execute the perfect line, especially if you have oily lids. Your natural oils can break down the formula and cause it to smudge or slide off, making all your efforts go to waste.
Although there’s nothing you can do to permanently fix oily eyelids, applying primer from a known organic makeup brand helps. By using a primer, you can ensure that your eyeliner sticks instead of slides.
On the other hand, the best solution is just to find the best eyeliner for oily lids.
Eyeliners add definition to make your eyes pop
Image via Pexels
Eyeliner can completely change your appreciation of beauty and intensify your eyes. It’s a necessary component of any makeup enthusiast’s palette.
Regular pencil eyeliner is a very versatile timeless classic. It can be used on the waterline for tight-lining and some blending. Pencil eyeliner goes on easily and can provide almost any look you crave.
They’re the best choice for those just starting out in the world of eyeliners. The only drawback is that pencils are not smudge-proof, they require constant sharpening, and they may not spread as smoothly as gel or liquid liners.
Liquid liner is a better choice for thin sharp lines and dramatic looks such as the cat-eye. Unlike pencil eyeliner, it’s not good to use this type of liner on your waterline.
Liquid liner is wet, making it a bit more difficult to master, so it’s not best for beginners. But these liners are great for endless, long-lasting, smudge-proof eye makeup fun.
Gel eyeliners are generally retractable or applied from a small pot with an eyeliner brush. This liner is soft, which makes it ideal for blending and tighter lining of the lid. It’s also safe to use on the waterline.
Unfortunately, over time the original point may become dull and cannot be sharpened. That said, retractable and pot gel eyeliners are a favorite, and good for both beginners and experts in the art.
No matter what form you choose, eyeliner outlines and emphasizes the eyes, adding glamour and distinction to your overall finish.
Shopping for the best deals
From pencils and liquids to creams and gels, eyeliner options are practically endless. So how do you shop for the right liner that won’t fade on your oily eyelids?
Eyeliners, including organic, are available at your local retail and drugstores. Many department stores carry all the brands you know and trust, although they sometimes can run in limited supply. But there’s an easy solution if you can’t seem to locate the best eyeliner for oily lids locally.
Most, if not all, cosmetic brands are available online from reliable retailers such as Amazon or the brand’s manufacturer website.
How much you should pay for eyeliner
Depending on the quality of the brand, we know that the cost of looking our best can set us back. The good news is those with sensitive or oily skin don’t necessarily have to pay extra for eco-friendly brands.
While shelling out $30 or more for a personal liner fave might be okay to some, many other high-end brands can achieve the same flawless look for less.
There are several solid organic makeup choices at a reasonable price, ranging as low as $ to $ and up.
We Found the Best Organic Eyeliners for You
The idea of “clean beauty” is evolving. Not too long ago you’d be hard-pressed to find even one organic cosmetic product, while today there are plenty. Finding a safe, perfect eyeliner among them all can feel like an infinite quest.
Besides price, each brand of eyeliner may come with its unique advantages and disadvantages as well.
But there’s no need to worry, for we have done all the homework for you. Based off of user and expert reviews, we can bring you the most crucial details about the different products available.
Below are a few product suggestions that you might find helpful when it comes to choosing the safest and best eyeliner for oily lids.
Alima Pure Natural Definition Eye Pencil
- Rich cocoa
- Formulated with hydrogenated jojoba oil, macadamia seed oil, and meadowfoam seed oil
- Contains nuts
If you want long-lasting performance, this highly pigmented eyeliner pencil should be at the top of your list. It goes on smoothly, blends beautifully, and can be layered easily with minimal smudging, even for those with oily lids.
Alima Pure lives up to the name, coming from pure nutrient-rich ingredients such as soothing chamomile extract and mango seed oil. This fragrance-free formula is also void of paraben impurities and isn’t tested on animals.
This liner is available in three excellent shades of carbon black, cocoa brown, and a shimmering taupe, at an affordable mid-price range of $ to $$.
This best eyeliner for oily lids “exceeds expectations” with its outstanding 5.0 out of 5-star rating on the manufacturer’s website.
VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil
- DRAMATIC DEFINITION - Define your eyes and make your lashes look fuller with our Kajal Waterline pencil. Now it’s...
- LONG LASTING - Uses a creamy, easy glide formula that offers one-stroke colour and a velvety matte finish that lasts all...
- SAFE FOR SENSITIVE EYES - Our pencil eyeliner is formulated for the most sensitive of eyes to give you comfort without...
Kajal Liner is formulated especially for use on your waterline and as the name suggests, sits comfortably on your upper or lower lid without causing irritation. By applying it to the waterline, it makes your lashes appear fuller and longer.
This premium black eyeliner is vegan-friendly, never tested on animals, and is free of parabens. Although it’s only currently available in jet black, the phenomenal waterline eye pencil brings bold intensity to your eyes. It’s opaque, applies smoothly, and stays set.
With little worry of smudging or fading, it offers you a defined, natural look, making it well worth the slightly higher price range of around $ to $$.
Many customers call this liner their waterline “favorite.” It’s apparent when you look at the high rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
- Results in beautifully defined eyes that will leave a lasting impression.
- The formula glides on with ease, dries quickly and won’t smudge, day-into-night
- Long lasting
The next liner on our list doesn’t have a reputation as “the best eyeliner for oily lids” for nothing. Stila’s Stay All Day liner will do exactly what it claims — it dries fast and stays put.
This waterproof liquid liner is available in nine different colors. It’s smooth to put on, and the color comes out vividly without the need of layering.
As with all products on this list, it uses only natural ingredients, omitting parabens and any other harmful additives.
With pricing, Stila is in the higher price range of $ to $$. But if the cost hasn’t turned you away, it is still a perfect choice for those with oily skin.
That said, it’s no surprise that this great eyeliner has a rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars on Amazon.
jane iredale Eye Pencil
- Formulated with botanical oils, waxes and butters
- Nourishing and comfortable to wear
- Easy to apply and long-lasting
This eye pencil is so soft and delicate that it won’t tug on the skin, even if you decide to blend it. It has natural pigments and it’s long-lasting, making it a great choice for those with oily lids.
Jane iredale has all the traditional liner colors covered including multiple shades of blacks, browns, and greys.
The pencil not only protects but also conditions your lids with shea butter and macadamia seed oil. This makes all-day wear not only possible but also comfortable.
Fortunately, this premium pencil doesn’t come at a premium price. Instead, it is available in the mid-price range of $ to $$.
It’s clearly understood why many customers call this eyeliner “fantastic” with its 4.1 out of 5-star rating on Amazon.
100% PURE Creamy Long Last Liner
- NATURAL SMOKEY EYE -- The dark brown pigment is perfect for adding depth and drama for a natural makeup look.
- MOISTURIZE ‘N GO -- Jojoba oil and shea butter moisturize skin for smooth, flawless application.
- CREAMY SOFT -- Nourishing plant butters feel gentle on skin, so this eye pencil won’t ever tug or pull on delicate...
Another best eyeliner for oily lids comes from 100% PURE. For anyone desiring a long-lasting, creamy pencil liner, this liner is just for you.
The 100% PURE line is also 100% cruelty-free. This formula has a creamy consistency due to its natural ingredients including jojoba oil, shea butter, and vitamin E.
It is available in four beautiful colors of black, dark cocoa, royal, and gleaming pewter, along with a higher-price range between $ to $$.
For a pencil eyeliner, it’s ridiculously smooth and glides on perfectly, but this makes it also quite easy to smudge. However, if you’re after a product to create a more smokey look, this is an excellent choice.
If you have a problem with smudging, it’s good to use a primer or setting powder before you apply it.
Price aside, this eyeliner “amazes” users with an overall rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars on the manufacturer’s website.
The Bottom Line: The Naturally Best Eyeliner for Oily Lids
Eyeliner is amazing. Whether you’re making a fancy cat-eye or just using it to define your lash lines, nobody should be without it. And if you stick to more natural brands, you’re not taking any risks.
We can ensure that each one of these products promises excellent quality and long-lasting wear. So even if you have oily eyelids, your liner will stay in place.
Did your favorite eyeliner not make our list? Please let us know what you think in the comments!
Featured Image via Pixabay