So you’re in the market for a new hammer. With a multitude of choices available, how do you know which one will be best for you?
From construction to material to balance, there are several things to consider before you buy. How often will you be using the hammer? Will it be augmenting an existing collection of hammers or will it be the only one you own?
Whether you are a professional carpenter or a newbie looking to purchase for the first time, our compilation of the top 10 best hammers reviewed in 2017 is a great place to begin your research.
Our guide checks price points, item details, and customer reviews to bring you an informative and thorough overview of excellent hammers on the market today.
Table of Contents
- 10. Stanley FatMax 51-944 Hammer
- 9. Vaughan 19-Ounce 17-Inch Max High Performance Framing Hammer
- 8. Stiletto Tools Inc TB15MS Ti-Bone Titanium Hammer
- 7. Dalluge 7180 16 Ounce Titanium Hammer
- 6. Estwing E20S 20 oz Straight Claw Hammer
- 5. Stiletto Tools TI14MC Titan 14-OunceTitanium Framing Hammer
- 4. Estwing Mfg Co. E3-16S Clay Hammer
- 3. Stiletto TB15MC TiBone Titanium Milled-Face Hammer
- 2. The Original Pink Box PB12HM Claw Hammer
- 1. Stanley 51-624 Rip Claw Fiberglass Hammer
- Which Hammer Should You Buy?
10. Stanley FatMax 51-944 Hammer
Made from double forged steel, this Stanley hammer is one continuous piece. With an ergonomically designed handle, this product aims to reduce fatigue in your hand and arm. Its anti-vibe technology reduces the amount of vibration traveling from the hammer to your arm.
For those customers needing to hammer for long periods of time, this feature is important. A rubber grip also makes this item ideal for framing and nailing. At $20.99, this hammer is affordable and dependable. Confident in their product’s durability, Stanley also offers it with a lifetime warranty.
- Customers especially appreciated this hammer’s anti-vibe feature–finding it surprisingly effective.
- Many reviews suggested that this Stanley product would make an excellent first hammer for someone.
- Users agree that this hammer has excellent balance, making it easy and powerful for minimal effort.
- Some reviews suggested that this particular item was not up to Stanley’s normal standards. They found it be poorly constructed.
- The shipping was also criticized as complaints cited the product arriving damaged.
9. Vaughan 19-Ounce 17-Inch Max High Performance Framing Hammer
This framing hammer from Vaughan is made in the United States and features milled face grips to prevent slipping. Its superior head to handle balance also greatly minimizes fatigue.
With a drop forged steel head, an extra long blue stained American hickory handle, and fully polished head, this product is both stylish and functional. Vaughan includes a magnetic nail holding slot to enhance this item’s efficiency.
- Users reportedly thought that the handle had an excellent angle–making it easy and comfortable to use.
- Affordability and quality construction were noted as key selling points.
- Customers loved the magnetic nail holding slot. They appreciated the efficiency this feature provided.
- Some reviews stated that this hammer was not durable–noting that the claw breaks easily.
- The most frequent complaint was that the item shipped was not blue. Many customers specifically wanted the blue hammer.
8. Stiletto Tools Inc TB15MS Ti-Bone Titanium Hammer
Made of light titanium, this hammer is built to reduce fatigue. It features a smart rubber compound on the handle that not only breathes, but also absorbs moisture.
A magnetic nail start on the nose increases this product’s efficiency. At $240.38, this Stiletto hammer is listed at a higher price point than its competitors. The manufacturer does provide a one year warranty.
- This hammer was reported to be both comfortable and efficient. Users felt that the balance was effective at reducing elbow fatigue.
- The nail starter feature was highly praised.
- Light and powerful, workers found the Stiletto Ti-Bone Titanium Hammer easy to carry on their tool belts and smooth to use.
- The high price point is one of the biggest drawbacks to this item.
- Some reviewers mentioned that the head loosened up from the handle–suggesting the construction quality was lower than expected.
7. Dalluge 7180 16 Ounce Titanium Hammer
The Dalluge hammer is composed of titanium and hickory. Lightweight yet durable, this product is built to last. Designed by a professional carpenter, it is well thought out with a side nail puller, an overstrike guard, and excellent head to handle balance. Although a bit more expensive at $99.06, this item offers a lot for the money.
- Customers praised the balance of this hammer.
- Many users said they loved the light weightedness. They felt that for lesson energy on their part, the hammer still delivered the same force as steel.
- While head to handle construction is an important feature when considering a hammer, the reviews of the Dalluge were all glowing.
- Some complaints highlighted the lack of durability in the waffle face. Users found that it wore very quickly.
- The handle was also reported to be weak–chipping easily.
6. Estwing E20S 20 oz Straight Claw Hammer
The Estwing name is synonymous with high quality construction and durability. Using their classic design for balance and temper, this hammer features a head and handle forged together in one piece.
A leather grip on the handle in combination with a fully polished handle make this product attractive as well as utilitarian. The exceptionally reasonable selling price of $29.98 makes this Estwing hammer a great buy.
- In keeping with its reputation, this hammer was found to be both solid and dependable.
- Users appreciated the item’s excellent balance and powerful swing.
- The high quality leather adds to the hammer’s curb appeal, which customers loved.
- Some complaints stated that the hammer arrived with a crooked handle.
- While the leather was visually stunning, there were a few reports of the material being too slippery–increasing the droppage rate.
5. Stiletto Tools TI14MC Titan 14-OunceTitanium Framing Hammer
This Stiletto hammer is made of titanium–a strong, lightweight material often used to reduce fatigue. Stiletto designed this hammer with an 18in long reach handle made of hickory. It also features a magnetic nail start feature. At $79.00, this product is affordable.
- Users approved of the balance and weight of this hammer.
- Several reviews stated that the titanium felt as powerful as steel.
- This product was found to be durable over time.
- Many customers were disappointed that this item is made in China. They would have preferred an American-made product.
- One user said that the magnet in the magnetic nail start broke within a month of use.
4. Estwing Mfg Co. E3-16S Clay Hammer
With a forged head and handle, Estwing continues its tradition of well-made products. This hammer features a nylon-vinyl deep cushion grip for increased hand comfort.
This material is stated to reduce shock by 70%. With fully polished steel and selling for $23.26, the Estwing Mfg. Co. E3-16S is a competitive hammer.
- Customers loved the texture of the handle grip. They felt that it greatly reduced the potential for slipping during use.
- Estwing has a history of durability and high quality. This hammer was reported to be no exception. Users felt is was long lasting.
- Many reviews agreed that this hammer is an excellent size for all carpentry needs.
- Complaints were made about the quality control. Some hammers arrived damaged.
- One user found there to be an annoying ring in the hammer when it was used.
3. Stiletto TB15MC TiBone Titanium Milled-Face Hammer
This hammer by Stiletto is on the high end of its selling group at $234.58. It has several attractive attributes, though, to defend its expensive price. Made of titanium, its weight comes in at 15oz–appreciated by anyone who has spent hours hammering.
It’s handle is also covered in a hardwearing rubber material for increased comfort. The solid grip increases the generation of power. Featuring replaceable steel faces, this hammer won’t wear out anytime soon.
- Customers praised this product’s high quality construction.
- Users admired and enjoyed the unique handle design and material.
- The replaceable heads were also a frequently mentioned selling point.
- This hammer’s price was one of customer’s biggest complaints.
- Some reports expressed disappointment that the milled face wore very quickly.
2. The Original Pink Box PB12HM Claw Hammer
This hammer is comprised of a fiberglass core with a resin coating. Fiberglass often reduces the vibration felt during use. An easy-to-grip rubber handle makes this item simple and dependable. It also features a smooth, polished face and bright, fun pink color.
Selling at $5.42 and accompanied by a limited lifetime warranty, the Original Pink Box PB12HM is an excellent choice for a basic hammer.
- Customers loved the color. They felt that it made the hammer easy to find and stylish at the same time.
- The affordability of this product was also appreciated.
- The rubber grip was reportedly solid and comfortable.
- Some users complained about the item’s weight. They found it to be too heavy.
- Construction was also disappointing to some customers. They found the head glued to the handle–a potentially unstable attachment.
1. Stanley 51-624 Rip Claw Fiberglass Hammer
Stanley makes its 51-624 Claw Hammer out of fiberglass. It features a textured rubber handle for a solid and comfortable grip. Stanley has heat treated and rim tempered this product–increasing its durability and dependability. Listed at $18.76, this is an excellent and affordable option.
- Users found the balance of this hammer to be excellent–making it easy to swing.
- Affordability and versatility were also praised.
- The sharp yellow color was also a key selling point as customers thought it made the hammer easier to find in a tool bag.
- Reviewers felt that the 20oz hammer was too big. They felt that the 16oz size was a better all-around choice.
- Some users felt that the hammer was a bit top heavy in its balance–making it feel as if the hammer was leading the swing.
Which Hammer Should You Buy?
So you’ve read our guide and you’re getting a clearer idea of what hammer will be best for you. Now would be an excellent time to swing by your local hardware store and try some out. Hold them, swing them, examine them to see which fits best in your hand.
While each of these products proves to be a satisfactory choice, we felt that customer reviews and product history combined with affordability made the Estwing Mfg Co. E3-16S a best buy. Regardless of your final choice, we think you’ll be happy with any one of these hammers.