Buying the correct eyebrow pencils can help you to produce the trending beautifully defined look that we are all striving to achieve instead of the dated, messy look that we all want to avoid reliving.
Browsing through your photos from the early ’90s will probably display you and your girlfriends enjoying fun times with over-plucked eyebrows that were messily drawn with poor quality eyebrow pencils.
Tweezing, perfecting and emphasizing our eyebrows to achieve the “eyebrows on fleek” look hadn’t started trending yet and probably would’ve looked bizarre to others.
Our brows must now be transformed to fit the times as we keep up with the fashion trends. The newest look has shifted to bold, full brows, and in the aftermath of the over-plucking trend in the late 1990s, we must now rely on the very best eyebrow pencils and products to resurrect and achieve a fuller look.
So, how do we whip our brows into perfect shape?
Read our reviews on the top 10 best eyebrow pencils in 2106 out there to help you to flawlessly create, shape and fill your brows. Your daily brow routine needs to be updated to gain the beautiful shape that we are all striving to achieve.
Table of Contents
- 10. Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil
- 9. The Precision Brow Pencil
- 8. Mac Eye Brows Eyebrow Crayon
- 7. T. Leclerc Eyebrow Pencil
- 6. Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil
- 5. Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
- 4. VDL, Festival Brow Pencil
- 3. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Soft Brown
- 2. Shiseido Natural Eyebrow Pencil
- 1. Shu Uemura Hard Formula Hard H9
- Which Eyebrow Pencil Should You Buy?
10. Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil
The Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Pencil is an ultrafine brow pencil that offers precision. The Dior brow pencil is recognized as the ultimate tool needed for perfected, defined, full and shaped brows that are runway-ready.
The Brow Styler will give your catwalk-quality eyebrows the essential finishing touches that are needed to steal the show, every time. The Dior Diorshow Styler uses one universally used shade along with an ultra fine tip that will provide every woman with a naturally spectacular look that matches her skin tone and hair color.
- Glides on easily without the need to press
- Ultrafine tip allows for perfecting an exact arch
- Ultrafine tip allows for perfected filling in of the brows
- The universal shade provides a natural color
- Review claims that the one-third of the pencil dried quickly and couldn’t be remoistened despite efforts to preserve its usefulness.
9. The Precision Brow Pencil
The Precision Brow Pencil by Kevyn Aucoin has won awards and is loved by many women. Kevyn designed this brow pencil to perfectly shape and contour your eyebrows. The super slim pencil is useful for filling in lighter areas in the brow, shaping and defining the brows.
The attached brow spoolie can be used to position the brows as you add color and definition. The brow pen provides long lasting, water resistant color with a retractable pencil design.
- Water Resistant
- Long lasting
- Smooth application
- Includes a spoolie
- May not hold well in warm or humid temperatures according to reviews
- Fragility mentioned in reviews – some claim it breaks easily
- No cap is included and the color can fall out of the holder
8. Mac Eye Brows Eyebrow Crayon
The Mac Eye Brows Eyebrow Crayon is brow defining power with a lasting self-propelling and self-sharpening design. The Mac Crayon confidently provides shape, color, texture and density in one tool.
Like the entire line of Mac products, this crayon has raving reviews and performs as was created to perform. This crayon acts as pen and creates just-right striking arches.
- Long lasting
- Reviews claim to have trouble with smudging during application
- Negative reviews claim dissatisfied with the crayon’s ability to last
7. T. Leclerc Eyebrow Pencil
The T. Leclerc Eyebrow Pencil is recognized by eyebrow makeup enthusiasts because of the fine, none waxy composition. The vegetable oil, beeswax and Carnauba wax-based tip should be honed before each use to provide the fine and exact, hair-like lines that allow you to fill inadequate spots in your brows and to add definition.
This is a long lasting pencil that is accompanied with a spoolie brush on the end of the pencil that may be used for prepping the brows and for smoothing and mixing the color. The spectacular look that you are seeking to achieve can be obtained with the T. Leclerc Eyebrow Pencil.
- Creates fine, hair-like lines to naturally fill in empty areas
- Includes an attached spoolie brush for shaping the brow
- Long lasting
- Should be honed before each use
- The wax composition may dry up when it isn’t adequately capped
6. Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil
The Revlon Brow Fantasy Pencil is available in many colors and uses a two-step process. The pencil’s pigment is used to fill and shape the brow and then the gel positions and sets the completed brow.
The final look is clearly defined with mix capable technology that adds color and a light hold that stays in place throughout the day. The gel can be used without adding color. Using the gel alone will give your brows a prepped look. The Brow Fantasy ranks in the top ten eyebrow pencils and has raving reviews.
- Pencil pigment adds color
- The gel allows you to position and set the browns
- Wide variety of colors to choose from
- The product is not hypoallergenic and some reviews shared that users experienced tingling and redness on their skin after using the product.
- Some reviews mention that their cap hasn’t been staying in place.
5. Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil glides on smoothly and its smudge-proof formula can stay in place throughout the day. The Define-A-Brow ultra-thin tip allows you to create a concise, perfect natural brow with a naturally soft finish.
Feathery strokes will provide a natural brow or bold strokes can create an eye-catching, trendy look. The attached comb is designed for versatility when creating your desired look.
Some reviews complain that the pencil snaps easily. It is suggested that the pencil should be twisted up gently and not forced. This pencil has raving reviews from many women who share their love for its quality and versatility.
- Smooth application
- Smudge proof
- Attached comb
- Creates a bold or natural look
- Some reviews mention that the comb isn’t useful
- The pencil may snap easily
4. VDL, Festival Brow Pencil
The VDL, Festival Brow Pencil has an angled, triangle shaped tip. This unique design provides flexibility. The angled tip helps you to position the pencil precisely as the triangle shape easily draws the perfect brow line. The VDL pencil glides on with powdery smooth with long lasting, smudge proof pigment.
The attached brush applicator enhances the natural appearance of the brow. Complimentary reviews agree that the pencil is costly but effective and long lasting. There are four colors on the palette for selection: Dark Brown, Gray Brown, Brown, Blonde
- Unique angled tip
- Triangle shaped for a perfect brow line
- Long lasting pencil
- Smudge proof
- Some reviews comment that the color selection may not be adequate
3. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Soft Brown
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz has a variety of colors to choose from. This allows you to choose a color that best matches your skin tone and blends with your hair color. The attached spoolie brush can be used to blend the color’s pigment into your skin while creating natural looking, smooth and even eyebrows.
The Brow Wiz may be on the expensive side, but reviews say that it is worth every penny. Gina review sums up the products many favorable reviews, “It has just the right texture, not too waxy, not too soft. It blends beautifully and any errors are easily cleaned up with a Q-Tip…. The staying power is amazing, too.”
- Number of colors to choose from
Attached spoolie for blending the pigment with the skin and hair
- A bit expensive
- Customer reviews include some complaints about the color stick breaking or falling out of the application pencil.
2. Shiseido Natural Eyebrow Pencil
The Shiseido eyebrow pencil is offered in a variety of colors and has a superb pigment that shapes the brow. The fine line application creates a smooth, clean look and the brush head blends the color well to complete great looking natural brows. The Shiseido Natural Eyebrow Pencil is easy to apply and the color can last the entire day without smearing.
- A variety of colors to choose from
- The fine line application combined with the brush head application completes the entire brow
- Lasts throughout the day without smearing
- Several customer reviews complain about the hard tip and having difficulty in applying the color.
- This caused them to press too hard on their skin.
1. Shu Uemura Hard Formula Hard H9
Shu Uemura Hard Formula Hard H9 eyebrow pencil is one of the top 5 best selling products by Shu Uemura. Shu Uemura has been recognized for the natural finish that its pencils produce. The hard formula allows the user to control the amount of color released. It can be applied heavy or soft.
This color will not be used on skin because it only releases color when it is combined with eyebrow hair oils. The pencil glides on smoothly and the application is almost undetectable to the user. This pencil must be sharpened based on use and it can be sharpened with a product like the Sword Shu Uemura sharpener or a Shu Uemura technician will sharpen it free of charge.
Eyebrows enhanced with the Shu Uemura Hard Formula Hard 9 eyebrow pencil add volume to the entire face. They provide a natural eyebrow shape that matches the natural color of the.
The pencil creates brows that make your face look perfected and more attractive. You must apply the Hard Formula pencil to regularly trimmed brows to experience an easy application and to create a clean, perfected look.
- Only releases color when it comes in contact with the eyebrow hair oils.
- Releases a perfect, natural looking color
- Smudge proof
- Long lasting
- Must be applied only to regularly, trimmed brows or the look may appear messy
Which Eyebrow Pencil Should You Buy?
The coveted “eyebrows on fleek” look is largely dependent on the use of excellent eyebrow pencil and makeup products. The ten listed eyebrow pencils are the top ten eyebrow pencils on the market and they have features that may be most beneficial for your brows.
They each have features that may interest you, such as a spoolie, a comb, crayon tip, wax tip, triangle shaped tip, ultra thin tip and so many other great features. It may be too hard to choose just one pencil from this list.
Eyebrows are one of the most important features on the face. A suitably colored and shaped brow will add definition, lift and style to your face, as it allows the light to accentuate your eyes.
Regularly trimming and shaping your brows will also ensure an easier and cleaner make-up application. Enjoy perfecting your brows and achieving the spectacular look that you desire. Click here to see the one I bought & use.